Richebourg 2008 Meo Camuzet

Avis professionnels

Robert Parker (93)

Meo-Camuzet’s 2008 Richebourg strikes me as their most obviously tannic wine of the vintage, despite the confitured intensity and plush richness of its black fruits. The effect of wood – whether or not this includes amplification of tannin – comes out here in a flattering way via a maple syrup-like amalgam of resin and caramel. Sweet, decadent floral perfume; brown spices; and crushed stone add palate interest, though the staining concentration of this wine’s finish is at least as yet somewhat undifferentiated and accompanied by gum-numbing intensity of tannin. When racked, this was “explosive” reports Meo, and the metaphor of a bomb sunk into the earth and topped with sandbags does strike me as potentially useful for a Pinot grand cru I would not want to touch for 5-7 years and which seems built to last for more than twice that long.

Winespectator (94)

Reserved now, this nascent red is concentrated, displaying black currant, violet, spice and mineral aromas and flavors, all matched to a silky texture. This is elegant and a picture of finesse, though there's structure on the back end. Shows fine harmony and length, but needs time.